Travis, You've got too much time on your hands! *LOL*
I agree with most of what you've written, and I appreciate you taking the time to pass on your knowledge.
One thing I can assure you though is that you can build muscle and lose fat at the same time. Done it many times myself. Done it for clients too.
Muscle is built from the repair and restoration of fibres, whereas fat is burnt as a fuel source. It's quite easy to combine this.
As I said before I'm no nutritionist. My strength is definately exercise. That being said, I've studied nutrition, chemistry, and physiology which at least gives me a better understanding than most. I've also had the privelage of working closely with many of this countries top dieticians so I've picked up a few things there as well.
The rest is just experience. I have worked with literally thousands of people over the past 15 years. The knowledge I've gained from that I'll try to pass on here!
Unfortunately, when it comes to nutrition there tends to be loads of confusion. For every study you find that supports a certain diet, you'll find one that dismisses it. The only way to know for sure is to find the eating styles that are backed by independant studies, and then give it a go.
What a good eating plan will have is a wide variety of fresh food. Meats, veges, pasta, rice, fruit, (good) fats, nuts, and more. You must have carbs. Low carb diets are very short term. You need carbs for energy. Yes, a gram of fat will provide much more energy than a gram of carbohydrates, but it takes much more to break it down so its less efficient. Now, that's not to say you should eat mostly carbs, you just need to find the right balance for you. Finally, you need to balance the calories (calories in vs calories out)
The beauty of forums like this is that everyone can express their opinions, and I'm sure the opinions expressed are backed by the posters own experiences. I will never say that one eating or exercise style definately won't work because I've seen many people lose weight with totally contrasting styles.
Man, I've got to get to bed!
Ray
Visit us at
The New Me Weight Loss Retreat